
Sorrentino, "The Great Beauty", 2013
Wednesday, September 19, 2018
While watching The Bicycle Thief, there were very dramatic scenes as well as scenes that weren't very realistic. Although, this film did paint a pretty accurate picture of poverty in Italy after the second World War. In reality, the film was overall pretty sad, since Antonio and his wife had to sell their sheets back to a company, just to buy the bike he needed to work once he finally got a job. And, by losing the bicycle, he lost the mobility to be able to work, and to be able to support his family during these tough times. The film also displays moments of irony, seeing as Antonio keeps running into the thief but can never actually catch him. Another ironic moment in the film was when nobody really helped him get his own bicycle back when it was stolen, but as soon as he attempted to steal a bike, he was caught instantly by people on foot. Overall, I couldn't see the underlying messages as well through the irony and some of the elements that made parts of the film seem unrealistic.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I liked what you said about the irony that was present in the film. In particular, I agree with what you noticed about no one helping him when his bike was stolen but having a mob after him when he tries to steal one. I wondered if, during the scene where Antoni has his bike stolen, the man who tries to help him afterwards is really just helping the thief by first blocking Antoni's path and then leading him in the opposite direction. It would only serve to lessen the irony of the film slightly if it were true, but it's most likely just a glimpse of what you already said: irony.
ReplyDeleteI agree completely with Jesyka's sentiment here. The contrived nature of situations in the film took away from the neorealistic perspective of the movie. In my opinion, straying from the neorealistic mold lessened the message of the movie. The "irony", or blatantly staged nature of some events, caused me to think of the movie as an isolated event. One of the main goals of neorealism was to give insight to issues plaguing the populace. Although this movie had many other aspect to it that made it a success, I agree that the irony of some key situations detracted from the movie as a whole.
ReplyDelete- Severino